Frozen Turtle Pie

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

 Today’s post is for an absolutely delicious Frozen Turtle Pie. I know it sounds decadent (and it is) but the beauty of it is that you can actually make it significantly lower in sugar with just a few substitutions.

Since we’re all hungry on Pie Day Fridays (because I just declared we were) I’ll keep this short and sweet and hop right to it!

Get your aprons on and fire up those mixers because HERE WE GO!

Let’s make Frozen Turtle Pie!

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

You’ll need: Caramel Topping, Sugar Free Chocolate Pudding (small box), Whipped Topping, Milk, Pecans, and Magic Shell.

You can get whatever caramel topping you prefer but let me tell ya, if y’all have an Aldi near you, that is where I got this jar and it is by far the absolute best I’ve ever tasted. I keep a jar of it in the fridge for caramel emergencies, which usually involve a spoonful from time to time. You know, just to keep my blood sugar regulated ~winks~

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

And you’ll need one of these.

This is a Chocolate Pie Crust.

Generic.

Because that’s how I roll...

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

So we take our milk and pour it into a mixing bowl and dump in our pudding mix…

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

Then we make like Michael Jackson and just beat it.

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

Then we dump in that tub of cool whip.

Lighten It Up! Did you notice I used “Lite” in this? Sure, the caramel has a lot of sugar in it but we can still use sugar free pudding and light cool whip. It will still have sugar but it will have a whole lot less. 

Little things make a difference, especially over time and this Frozen Turtle Pie is no less decadent because of it!

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

We then have a nice creamy pudding but the beauty of this is, after you freeze it, it tastes just like chocolate ice cream.

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

Pour about a cup of that luscious caramel into your chocolate pie crust.

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

Then tilt it a bit until the caramel covers the bottom.

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

Sprinkle pecans all over that.

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

Spoon all of the pudding mixture over it. It will be very full.

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

Now Cover it and freeze.

See the handy thing about using a store bought crust for this is that great little cover!

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

When you’re ready to serve, remove from freezer and squirt a border of frozen whipped cream around the edges.

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

ZigZag some Magic Shell over it and place that in the freezer for about five minutes, uncovered, just to solidify the magic shell over the whipped cream part.

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

Stick some pecans around the border if you like.

Ain’t it purty?

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

Lookie there!

Oh mercy…..

Frozen Turtle Pie from SouthernPlate

Serve this delicious Frozen Turtle Pie to your favorite people or just keep it stored in the freezer and ration it out a piece at a time, to yourself!

Frozen turtle pie

Frozen Turtle Pie sounds decadent (and it is) but the beauty of it is that you can make it significantly lower in sugar with just a few substitutions!
Prep Time: 20 minutes
Total Time: 20 minutes
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Keyword: pie
Servings: 4
Calories: 390kcal

Ingredients

  • Small box instant chocolate pudding can use sugar free - 4 serving size
  • 1 +1/2 cup milk
  • 8 ounce container whipped topping Can use light
  • 1 cup caramel
  • 6 ounce chocolate pie crust
  • 1 cup chopped pecans
  • Chocolate Magic Shell
  • squirt whipped cream canned, for garnish
  • pecan halves to garnish

Instructions

  • In large mixing bowl, place instant pudding and milk. Beat well, scraping down sides as needed, until pudding is dissolved, about two minutes. Add in whipped topping and mix until well blended, about a minute.
  • Spread caramel in the bottom of pie crust. Sprinkle with chopped pecans. Spoon Chocolate Pudding mixture over. Cover and place in freezer until firm.
  • Before serving,squirt a border of canned whipped topping around the edges. Drizzle a zig zag pattern of magic shell over the entire top of the pie and place in freezer, uncovered, for five minute to help set.
  • Press pecans into the border for decoration, if desired. Allow to sit out for five to ten minutes before cutting. Enjoy!

Nutrition

Calories: 390kcal
Tried this recipe?Mention @southernplate or tag #southernplate!

You may also like these other Turtle Dessert recipes:

Super Easy Turtle Cookie Bars

Texas Turtle Sheet Cake

Homemade Turtles,

WHAT YOU ARE TO BE —YOU ARE NOW BECOMING.

~Unknown. Submitted by Tom Crews

 

Similar Posts

88 Comments

  1. Yum!! This sounds wonderful!

    Happy Mother’s Day to you. I love being a part of your Southern
    Plate Family. You really make us feel a part of your family!!

    Pam

  2. You Rock … & you don’t even understand HOW MUCH YOU ARE APPRECIATED!!!

    Please Keep On Keepin’ On!! Ma’am!

  3. I’ve made your Frozen Turtle Pie before and it’s a hit with my family! My nine year old son actually requested that I make this pie for his birthday instead of a traditional birthday cake. That is some high praise coming from him!!

  4. I definitely will be making this this summer! (I just realized I had “this” back to back!)

  5. I’m making this tonight! My and dad’s birthdays are tomorrow, and I prefer birthday pie to birthday cake. I’m using the lite whipped topping and sugar free pudding like you suggested. I’m also going to use almond milk, and I made caramel from condensed milk. Hopefully it will still taste as yummy with all those calorie cuts. I’ll let you know!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe or Post Rating